Episode 011  ·  August 4, 2026

Nick Merritt

I Killed That Old Man

Nick Merritt is an Army officer and PSYOP detachment commander whose infidelity ended his first marriage and sent him into years of self-hatred, before a sermon on forgiveness finally set him free.

Nick Merritt: I Killed That Old Man

Nick Merritt sits down with Dan Black just 48 hours after Dan felt led to ask him, no prep, no back and forth, both of them going in cold. Nick is an Army officer and PSYOP detachment commander who was unfaithful to his first wife early in his military career, a betrayal that ended the marriage and sent him into years of self-hatred and blackout drinking alone at Fort Campbell. God had already forgiven him. His ex-wife had already forgiven him. It took a sermon years later to teach him the one person who hadn't forgiven him yet was himself. The conversation closes with Nick standing at a real crossroads, days from leaving the PSYOP work he loves to requalify into an entirely new Army career built around nuclear weapons policy, still not certain if it's God's calling or just a good opportunity.

Military Veteran PSYOP Special Operations Faith Infidelity Forgiveness Self-Forgiveness Redemption Depression Christian Testimony Marriage
The Story

Nick Merritt grew up in Maryland the grandson of a career preacher, in a household where faith was present but never personal. He has almost no memories of his childhood before middle school, a gap he links to abuse both from his mother's first husband and later from his own father, abuse severe enough that he and his siblings sometimes had to be locked in a closet for safety. He was raised instead by the man his mother met when he was a toddler, the father he claims today. He played sports through high school, drifted through a rough first semester of college, and eventually found stability studying exercise science and meeting the woman who would become his first wife.

Nick enlisted in the Army at 29 after a Tough Mudder convinced him he was wasting his physical ability behind a desk. But the life he was building came apart when he was unfaithful to his first wife while the two were stationed apart early in his career. She found out, they tried to reconcile over video calls, and it ended in divorce. Alone at Fort Campbell in a new job with no support system, Nick spiraled into what he calls a deep, dark hole of depression, drinking alone most nights until he blacked out just to sleep, then repeating it the next day for years.

"Instead of letting that old man die, I killed that old man. That was a very long process, years and years and years of just self-hatred, self-loathing."

A rejected call to Special Forces recruiting pushed him instead toward Psychological Operations, where he found both a career and, eventually, his current wife, whom he met on Facebook Dating during the pandemic. On their first date he made the deliberate choice to be honest with her about his past rather than lie again, a decision he credits as the start of everything that followed. She brought him to Grace Church, where a sermon on what the church calls the freedom cycle became the only message he can say completely changed his life: he had long known God had forgiven him, and that his ex-wife had forgiven him, but had never once forgiven himself.

"God forgives you. The other person forgives you. You have to forgive yourself."

What followed was not a single dramatic moment but a slow, visible transformation, most clearly tracked in how he engages with worship, moving from standing silently in the back to now singing every word with his hands raised, sometimes moved to tears by songs about his family. He built a discipline of praying before public speaking and says his confidence has been unmistakably different ever since. At home, he and his wife pray nightly, raise two daughters in a house full of scripture and worship music, and serve together nearly every Tuesday night feeding and praying with people in need through a ministry called Moore Manna.

Today Nick is a PSYOP officer who currently oversees PSYOP Assessment and Selection, a different program from the Special Forces Assessment and Selection that turned him away years earlier. In less than a week from this conversation, he leaves for two months to requalify into an entirely new Army career field built around nuclear weapons policy, work that connects to graduate study he never finished. He is honest that he still does not know for certain whether this next chapter is God's specific calling or simply an opportunity that checked every box he personally wanted.

From This Episode
"I was really in a deep dark hole depression and I didn't have anybody to help me through that."
— On the years after his divorce
"I look back at it sometimes and I was like what was I thinking? I wasn't."
— On his infidelity
"We had to get locked in the closet so that we could be protected."
— On childhood abuse
"There's nothing special about me. I don't know why anyone would want to hear what I have to say."
— On being asked to share his story
"I am a family man. They're my reason for existence. I live to serve them."
— On his wife and daughters
"I don't think somebody who's genuinely happy would do the things that I had done."
— Nick Merritt
Scripture
1 Samuel: David and Goliath
Raised by Dan near the close, using how everyone underestimated David to prompt Nick to consider who he personally underestimates. Nick's answer, after reflection, was his own wife.
The Blood of the Lamb and the Power of Testimony
Alluded to by Dan in discussing why an honest, unpolished testimony matters more than a curated one, and why Nick's willingness to admit he has no dramatic conversion moment is itself valuable.
The Freedom Cycle
Pastor Ryan's sermon at Grace Church that Nick says is the only message that has ever completely changed him, centered on the idea that God forgives, others forgive, and you still have to forgive yourself.
Topics Covered
Childhood in North Carolina and Maryland
Domestic abuse and being locked in a closet for safety
Being raised by a stepfather he calls his real father
A grandfather who preached for 50 years
College, a rough first semester, and exercise science
A Tough Mudder as the catalyst for enlisting
Enlisting in the Army at 29
Infidelity and the end of his first marriage
Blackout drinking and depression at Fort Campbell
Turned away by Special Forces recruiting
Finding PSYOP and a Balkans deployment
Missing his baby's first birthday during deployment
Meeting his wife on Facebook Dating
Choosing honesty over another lie on their first date
Grace Church and the freedom cycle sermon
Forgiving himself after already being forgiven
A slow transformation in worship engagement
Praying before public speaking
Family prayer and the Moore Manna outreach ministry
Leadership before and after his faith transformed
Transitioning to a new career in nuclear weapons policy
Uncertainty about discerning God's calling